Steve: I will admit that I am just relearning MTP so I am in simulation mode. BUT, I have read your entire manual, listened to many of the webinars, read all your Advanced Blogs and applied what you have been teaching. I got the TS3 short and then reversed on the DP which even had a VSA for added confirmation!!!! I used the ATR stop since the oscillator went through the band so I got stopped out, but what I find incredible is that price eventually went to the DP profit target zone and reversed again!!!! I feel that even I could have written your blog today because of how well you teach. Thanks for your great instruction and for answering all of my questions. Again a Million Thanks for your great education!!!!!!!!!!
Greg, Private Trader
Please understand that the comments in this web site are only a personal observation from my own experience, but it is one that appears to reflect many Elliott wave analysts I have met during my 29 years involved in the markets. The normal sequence of events goes something like this…
Firstly, the budding Elliott wave analyst hears about Elliott waves on some chat room or from another trader, and then goes and purchases an Elliott wave book or trading course. They then spend months carefully studying all of the rules and guidelines with the aim of becoming fluent in Elliott wave analysis. They then try to apply the rules and guidelines they have learnt to real and live market examples, normally with limited success. You can always spot a new Elliott wave analyst because they always have the most current bar ending some sort of complicated wave structure, with labels of varying degree all over their chart. They then make a forecast that must be correct because everything is perfect and all the rules have been obeyed on their chart.
However, the market usually goes the other way, resulting in a trading loss. They usually try this on a number of charts over a few weeks or months, with most of the charts moving in exactly the opposite direction to anticipated. Sometimes the Elliott student will have one great success, and call the exact day of a market turn, which normally makes them deny or carefully forget more of the not-so-good recent calls on other markets. But usually, at some point, the student admits that most of their calls are not working out as anticipated.
I have seen this all too often over the last 25 years – Basically, no matter now perfect the current wave count seems, it very often break down at some point in the future. As such the current forecast you have does not work out as anticipated.
So why should the theory break down so often? It is because Markets go through Cycles, they have periods of clarity, where the pattern is clear and can be used, then they also have periods of uncertanity, when the pattern is unclear. I call this the "The Cyclical Nature of Trading". The only practical way round this is to accept that Elliott wave analysis only works about 50% of the time. In other words, an easy to recognise and obvious wave count only exists on ½ the charts you look at or will only work about ½ the time while you are looking at one market.
So is there an answer ? And more importantly, can Elliott Wave (with all its shorfalls) be used as a succesful trading approach ? I am glad to say that the answer is yes, please see the next section.